Jaclyn Reiswig brought a copy of her own novel, Second Life, to New York. Just in case.
She didn’t really expect Tom Hiddleston to sign it.
Then she took a Chelsea Market food tour, struck up a conversation with her guide, Meri, and learned something that would create an incredible full circle moment.
But to appreciate what happened at that stage door, you have to go back to the book.
Watch Jaclyn’s full-circle moment
Her husband captured the encounter in this 22-second video.
First, she wrote him into the story
Years before her first visit to New York, Jaclyn saw a series of photographs of celebrities riding the London Underground. A lifelong love of London, a celebrity crush, and a delicious what-if started coming together in her mind.
What would happen if you bumped into a British actor on the Tube?
That idea became Second Life, the novel she published at the end of 2017. With young children at home, it had taken her a couple of years to finish.
Her fictional actor, Wes, was inspired by a crush on Tom Hiddleston. As Jaclyn describes him, he “looks like Tom, talks like Tom.”
She also gave Wes a love of Shakespeare. And because Much Ado About Nothing was her favorite play, she cast him as Benedick. When readers meet Wes, he is preparing for the role.
Years later, Jaclyn learned that the real Tom Hiddleston would be playing the very same character.
“I could not BELIEVE it when I saw he was playing Benedick,” she told us. “What are the chances?!”
By then, the production had finished its London run and was headed to New York. Jaclyn and her husband had been talking about visiting NYC for years.
“I told my husband we had to go. No alternative.”

The conversation that changed her plans
During their visit, the couple joined our Chelsea Market tour with our tour guide Meri. Meri asked what else they had planned in the city. Jaclyn told her about the show. Then she told her about the book. “She was almost as blown away by the coincidence as I was!”
Meri had a suggestion: actors sometimes greet theatergoers at the stage door after a performance. Perhaps Jaclyn could get her book signed.
For a first-time visitor attending her first New York theater performance, this was news.
“I had brought a copy along just in case, but I really didn’t think it would happen,” Jaclyn said.
“The only reason I knew to ask about it at the theater was because Meri had told me.”
Before they parted, Meri asked her to let her know how it went.
“You wrote this?”
At the theater, Jaclyn and her husband were seated on the opposite side from the exit doors. Getting to the front of a stage-door crowd seemed unlikely.
But when she asked about it, the theater staff helped. A security guard told her to call for him once she got outside. When she did, he motioned the couple up front.
Then there was Tom, moving along the row, signing playbills.
As he approached, Jaclyn quickly explained the connection: her book, the character he had inspired, and the Shakespeare role she had imagined for him years before. According to Jaclyn, he responded: “You wrote this?” Then: “Amazing!”
He asked whether she wanted him to sign her book. “Yes, yes I did,” she recalled.
The novel she had packed on the off chance was now signed by the actor who had helped inspire it.

Her husband captured the encounter in a 22-second video. But his description of what happened afterward might be the best review of the evening: in 25 years of marriage, he had never seen her so giddy.
Their daughter had a response of her own.
“I think my daughter summed it up when she called me afterward and just squealed for about 20 straight seconds.”
The New York she hadn’t expected
The autograph wasn’t the only thing Jaclyn took home.
Before the trip, she had heard plenty about New Yorkers being rude to tourists. Her experience was the opposite.
“Not just that night! Our entire visit, New Yorkers were helpful to us.”
As the holidays approach, this is the kind of New York story we love sharing. A trip planned together. A small kindness that becomes part of a family’s favorite story.
Jaclyn had long called London her favorite city in the world. Now, she says, New York might be tied. Our hearts are warmed!
A Broadway tip to tuck into your plans
If you’re seeing a Broadway show, ask theater staff whether there is a designated stage-door area and what the arrangements are for that performance. Some actors may stop to sign playbills or greet fans afterward, but appearances and autographs are never guaranteed.
Follow staff instructions, keep exits and sidewalks clear, and respect any limits on photos or signatures. Think of it as a possible bonus to a wonderful evening.
And if you’re joining a tour earlier in your trip, tell your guide what you’re excited about. A show, a favorite food, a neighborhood you’ve always wanted to explore. Those conversations give your guide a chance to offer something personal.
For Jaclyn, it began with Meri asking what else she was doing in New York.
Come for the food. Bring your curiosity.
At Like A Local Tours, we love introducing guests to the food, neighborhoods, and people that make this city worth exploring. Our guides bring their own interests and local knowledge to those conversations, and we’re especially proud of the care Meri showed Jaclyn.
Planning a holiday visit, or a day in the city with someone you love? Explore our NYC tours, and leave a little room in your plans for a good conversation.
You might go home with a new favorite place. You might go home with a story you’ll be telling for years.

